Overview
What this book is about
Electromagnetism and Life is the technical monograph behind Becker's later popular books. It is a dense review, with hundreds of references, of what was known by about 1981 about electricity, magnetism and living things. It draws on Western and Soviet-bloc literature; many of the Soviet papers are cited through US government translations (JPRS reports). The preface says Becker wrote the history and "bioregulatory" parts and Marino wrote the parts on the effects of man-made fields. The authors deliberately leave out heat and electric shock, which they call "well-understood but relatively unimportant." Their subject is effects below the heating level ("subthermal"), which they say "seem destined to revolutionize the study of biology." They admit that their testimony on non-thermal effects in the 1970s made them powerful enemies. They say they have tried to keep that fight out of the analysis, and they warn readers that some of their judgments will turn out to be wrong in what is a first attempt at a synthesis.
The book makes one argument in three steps. First, living things have their own electrical control system: a slow, analog, direct-current (DC) system carried in the cells that surround the nerves. It works alongside the fast "digital" nerve impulse, and it governs how excitable the nerves are and how growth, healing and regeneration proceed. Bone adds a piezoelectric, semiconductor-like "self-organizing" system of its own. Second, organisms detect the Earth's natural electromagnetic background and use it. It sets the timing of biological cycles, it helps animals navigate, and magnetic-pole reversals appear to have driven extinctions. Third, if both are true, man-made fields should affect biology at far below heating levels. Chapters 5–8 go through the evidence system by system: nervous, endocrine, cardiovascular, blood, immune, metabolic, reproductive, growth and genetic.
The authors conclude that "there is no biological function which can be said to be impervious to nonthermal EMFs." Their unifying model is Hans Selye's stress theory. The central nervous system detects a field that the person cannot consciously perceive, and the body then mounts a general, adaptive stress response. That response is usually reversible, but it uses up reserve capacity. It becomes harmful when exposure is too long or too strong, or when other stressors are present at the same time. Chapter 10 applies this to real life. Environmental field levels from broadcast towers, radar, power lines and appliances fall in the range that was active in the laboratory. Epidemiological and occupational studies show a scatter of stress-type illness rather than one specific disease, which is what the stress model predicts. The US heating-based limit of 10,000 µW/cm² protects only against heating. The Soviet limits of 10 µW/cm² for workers and 1 µW/cm² for the public were, in the authors' words, "the correct one."
The tone is academic and measured. The authors regularly report negative and failed-replication studies (Battelle, Fulton, Preston, Gould & Able, Martin & Gutman). They devote a whole section to "uncontrolled variables" that can make the same experiment give opposite results. This is the evidence base that The Body Electric and Cross Currents popularise; Marino's memoir Going Somewhere tells the story of writing it and of the controversy around it. The book predates cell phones, Wi-Fi and Bluetooth. Its relevance to headphones is through general principles, not device data.
Key Ideas
The core frameworks and findings
Contents
Chapter by chapter — click to expand
- Sets out the claim that intrinsic electrical phenomena are vital, that the natural electromagnetic background is "an important environmental factor for all living things," and that man-made fields may have changed the Earth's electromagnetic background more than any other physical feature of the planet. Says who wrote which part (Becker: history and bioregulation; Marino: bioeffects of artificial fields). Excludes heat and shock. The "King Canute" remark about opposition to their 1970s testimony. Acknowledges Szent-Györgyi, Frank Brown, Frey, Zaret and Cope, and in the USSR Presman, Kholodov, Sadchikova and Udintsev. Thanks colleague Maria Reichmanis.
- Effects of very weak forces fall into two groups: central nervous system effects (electrical anaesthesia, eel migration, pigeon navigation, biocycle timing, extinctions at magnetic reversals) and growth effects (bone, limb regeneration, tumour inhibition, flatworm polarity).
- The "solid-state" hypothesis of life's origin: a self-repairing semiconducting crystal system that was never discarded. What such a system should look like today. Chapter-by-chapter roadmap.
- Mechanism versus vitalism, and electricity cast as the vitalists' "life force."
- From Hippocrates, Galen and Vesalius to Gilbert's De magnete (1600), Bacon, Harvey, Descartes and Newton's "aether." Stephen Gray's conduction experiments; Hales's proposal that nerves conduct "electrical powers."
- Galvani's "animal electricity" (1786/1791). Volta's bimetallic counter-theory and the Voltaic pile. Humboldt (1797) shows both were partly right. Aldini treated a patient who would now be called schizophrenic with currents through the head.
- Oersted discovers electromagnetism (1820). Matteucci proves the current of injury. Du Bois-Reymond discovers the nerve impulse; Helmholtz times it at 30 m/s. Bernstein's membrane hypothesis (1868) removes electricity from biology.
- About 10,000 US physicians were using electrotherapy by 1884. The Flexner Report (1910) and the drug industry end it. Edison-era "no effect" tests versus d'Arsonval's and Beer's magnetic phosphenes (flashes of light seen in a changing magnetic field).
- Anomalies that persisted: Leduc's electronarcosis (1902; 110 Hz at 35 V), Cerletti's electroshock (1938), Berger's EEG (1929), Burr's and Lund's bioelectric fields, Leao's spreading depression, Gerard & Libet. Loewi's chemical synapse and Hodgkin–Huxley–Eccles complete the chemical picture.
- Szent-Györgyi's 1941 Koranyi lecture proposes semiconduction in proteins: "some basic fact about life is still missing."
- Introduction: World War II science brings transistors, cybernetics (Wiener, von Neumann, McCulloch) and sensitive instruments, but biology largely ignores Szent-Györgyi.
- The Nervous System: Gerard & Libet's DC gradients and traveling waves. Leao's spreading depression. Caspers's DC shifts with activity and sleep. Terzuolo & Bullock: tiny currents modulate neuron firing. Electronarcosis and electrosleep (Nias 1976, double-blind). Glia (Kuffler & Potter; Walker). Sensory receptors as analog transducers: the Pacinian corpuscle behaves like a piezoelectric material. Becker's salamander surface field (1960), nerve polarity, freezing and Hall-effect experiments. Front-to-back head current and anaesthesia (30 µA; 3,000 G). Baule & McFee's heart magnetic field (1963). Cohen's SQUID magnetoencephalogram (1972). Conclusion: a two-part CNS, with an analog DC system in the perineural cells and a digital action-potential system in the neurones.
- Growth Control: Frazee (1909). Marsh & Beams's flatworm head–tail reversal. Humphrey & Seal's tumour regression. Huggins & Yang on carcinogens and electron transfer. Denervation and tumours (Hasson; Pawlowski & Weddell). Singer's nerve threshold. Rose's and Polezhayev's frog regeneration. The current of injury in salamander vs frog and the two-phase theory of regeneration. Smith's frog limbs. Becker's rat forelimb (1972; later confirmed by Libbin and Smith). Rose's denervated salamanders with applied current. The neuroepidermal junction and the rat sciatic-nerve experiment. Frog red-cell dedifferentiation (Harrington; Pilla).
- Bone: Wolff's law as a negative-feedback control loop. Collagen–apatite structure. Yasuda's and Fukada's piezoelectricity. Bassett & Becker's rectification. The PN-junction model. Growth at the cathode (<3 µA). Copper-ion binding sites and EPR evidence that collagen and apatite share identical binding sites. Bone as the first identified "self-organizing system."
- Summary: the perineural DC system is a data-transmission and control system (input: injury; output: growth, healing and "biasing" of neurones). It offers therapeutic promise for regeneration, pain and anaesthesia, and a possible link to environmental fields.
- Introduction: the richness of the natural background. The Earth's field (about 0.5 G) with its circadian variation, micropulsations of 0.01–20 Hz, magnetic storms, lightning "whistlers," telluric currents and the Earth–ionosphere cavity. Old "cosmic influence" beliefs (Paracelsus, Mesmer, "ill winds").
- Evolution of Life: the Miller–Oparin–Fox theory of life's origin and the problem of single-handed (chiral) molecules. Cole & Graf's 10-Hz Precambrian cavity resonance, which would have produced one-handed, helical molecules (supported by Thiermann & Jarzak). Magnetic reversals. Uffen's radiation theory rejected. Radiolarian extinctions at reversals (Harrison & Funnell; Hays), and Hays's idea that sensitivity increases with evolutionary advance. Permian and Cretaceous extinctions. The last reversal about 25,000 years ago, and the next cannot be predicted.
- Biological Cycles: Frank Brown's oysters (1954) and Nassarius snails. Arrhenius. König's diurnal 10-Hz variation. The same rhythms in potatoes, fruit flies, mice and human lymphocyte counts. Wever's shielded and unshielded bunkers and the restorative 10-Hz field.
- Positional and Navigational Aids: monarch butterflies, Arctic terns, homing salamanders, palolo worms. Von Frisch's bees. Kramer's and Yeagley's pigeons. The inadequate one-pigeon "refutation." Keeton's magnets and translucent contact lenses. Walcott & Green's head coils. Blakemore's magnetotactic bacteria. Magnetite in bees (Gould) and pigeon skulls (Walcott). Baker's human homing vs Gould & Able. Electrosensing in eels (Rommel & McCleave). Conclusion: the relationship between organisms and the field is subtle but billions of years old, so artificial fields matter.
- Introduction: why electrical properties that do not fit orthodox concepts deserve study.
- Energy Bands: conductors, insulators and semiconductors. Szent-Györgyi's shared energy levels, Evans & Gergely, impurity doping. His ascorbate–methylglyoxal model of protein activation. Water makes measurement hard.
- Piezoelectricity: found in tendon, dentin, aorta, trachea, intestine, elastin, nucleic acids and others. The bone constant d14. The authors' femur growth simulation. The converse effect (McElhaney; Martin & Gutman). Pyroelectricity (Lang), ferroelectricity (Athenstaedt), bone electrets (Mascarenhas; Fukada).
- Superconductivity: predictions of room-temperature organic superconductivity (Little, Ginzburg). Superconductivity found in bile salts (Halpern & Wolf) and in lysozyme solution (Ahmed et al.). Cope's analysis of six biological processes consistent with superconductive tunnelling.
- Techniques of Application of Electromagnetic Fields: electric-field plates, magnetic coils (including the Navy's human exposure coil at Pensacola) and plane-wave radiation (µW/cm²). Internal "dose" cannot be calculated, since model estimates vary 2–100×, so results are reported by the applied field. Animals of different shapes distort a field differently, so rat results do not map directly onto monkeys or people.
- Summary: tissue shows essentially all the solid-state properties of ordinary materials. Nothing precludes specific effects, so "it is necessary to do the experiment." Also defines "EMFs" as the book's collective term for electric fields, magnetic fields and radiation.
- Introduction: people have no receptors for EMFs, but nothing rules out subliminal detection. The chapter distinguishes primary effects on the nervous system from indirect effects on other organs.
- Direct Effects:
- EEG and magnetic fields: salamander EEG under strong fields; Kholodov and Chizhenkova's rabbit spindles and slow waves, with after-effects, and the hypothalamus and cortex most reactive.
- EEG and electric fields: DC field effects (Lott & McCain).
- EEG and microwaves: X-band after-effects that "resembled those induced by hallucinogenic drugs" (Goldstein); rises and falls in slow-wave activity at 3 GHz and 50 MHz; pulse-frequency entrainment (Servantie; Bawin).
- Frey's work on evoked potentials, behaviour and "hearing phenomena," and on the blood-brain barrier (with Oscar & Hawkins, and Preston's negative result).
- Brain chemistry: norepinephrine, the acetylcholine enzymes (ChAC and cholinesterase) and cytochrome oxidase.
- Brain tissue changes: Kholodov's findings versus Friedman's zoonosis explanation; Tolgskaya's hypothalamic neurosecretion.
- Behavioral Effects:
- Motor activity: first more active, then less, with microwaves; increased activity at 50/60 Hz.
- Aggression, escape, avoidance and sleep.
- Human reaction time (König & Ankermüller; Hamer; Friedman; Persinger) and the 60-Hz, 1-gauss adding-task study.
- Ross Adey's timing-behaviour and calcium-efflux studies (147 MHz modulated at 6–10 Hz; 450 MHz at 16 Hz) and Grodsky's membrane model.
- Operant and conditioned responses: microwaves strengthened a sedative's effect on behaviour (Thomas).
- Summary: the energy delivered was too low to drive the effects directly, so metabolism supplies the energy and the field acts as a trigger. The effects were largely non-specific to frequency and field type but depended on pulse and modulation. There was no dose-response. The subject's state mattered. The pattern is detection plus adaptation, which introduces Selye's stress concept.
- Introduction: an outline of the glands (parathyroid, thyroid, pancreatic islets, adrenal cortex and medulla, pituitary). EMFs might act on a gland directly or through the brain and pituitary. Studies covered: Friedman & Carey's monkeys; Marino's rats at 15 kV/m, 60 Hz; Novitskiy's full hypothalamus–pituitary–adrenal chain at 2.4 GHz; antidiuretic-hormone rise and lower urine flow.
- The Adrenal Cortex: stress-hormone levels change over time and with field strength (500–5,000 V/m, 50 Hz, over 4 months; reversible within 2 months). Udintsev on continuous versus intermittent 200-G fields. Microwave studies at 3 and 60 GHz. Demokidova's adrenal weights at 3 GHz, 70 MHz and 15 MHz. Histological changes.
- The Thyroid: stimulated by high frequencies (70 MHz, 3 GHz); depressed at 50 Hz, 1–15 kV/m, reversible within 6 weeks. Prenatal 0.5-Hz exposure enlarged the thyroid (Ossenkopp; Persinger).
- The Adrenal Medulla and the Pancreatic Islets: catecholamines went through phases for 7–14 days after one day at 200 G. Chronic 90 G raised adrenal catecholamines; the adrenal medulla enlarged 60% at 70 MHz. Insulin insufficiency, with blood glucose up 37% after intermittent exposure.
- Summary: EMFs are biological stressors. Most effects are compensatory, but adaptation lowers the capacity to cope with a second stressor. Uncontrolled variables and opposite individual responses make group averages insensitive. Only Udintsev had studied one field (200 G, 50 Hz) systematically.
- Introduction: possible routes to the heart and blood, directly or through the CNS.
- The Cardiovascular System: longer PR and QRS intervals in mice (100 kV/m, 1,000 h). Arrhythmia in guinea pigs. Slow heart rate in rats from 50 V/m (Fischer) and in rabbits at 1,000 V/m but not at 500 or 100 V/m, with smaller ECG waves and less reserve capacity. Similar changes with microwaves at 0.5–3 V/m. Dogs' blood-pressure and heart-rate response to a controlled bleed at 15 kV/m. Blood pressure first rose, then fell for months at 3 GHz, 153 µW/cm².
- Blood: white and red cell counts under power-frequency fields (Graves; Meda). Guinea pigs at 3 GHz: individual animals shifted in opposite directions, and averages hid it until 500 µW/cm². Gonchar's neutrophil glycogen at 2.4 GHz. Lower red-cell production at 2.95 GHz, with pulsed fields acting sooner than continuous ones. Red cells fell 15% at 130 G. Marino's crossover mouse design showing a response to change in the electrical environment. Clotting and blood-protein shifts.
- Immune Response: Szmigielski's staph-infected rabbits. Udintsev's Listeria mice. Neutrophil killing activity (Shandala & Vinogradov; 14.88 MHz for 10 months). Antibody-forming cells and adaptation at 12 weeks (Czerski). Microwave pre-treatment changed the immune response to formaldehyde and carbon monoxide. Bone-marrow stem-cell rhythms and megakaryocytes. Delayed inflammatory response under 600–3,800 G DC. Battelle's negative 60-Hz findings.
- Summary: slow heart rate, less reserve and blood-pressure changes, similar to findings in exposed workers. Blood changes depend on time and on changes in exposure. Impaired immunity fits a body whose reserve is already spent on adapting.
- Introduction: many experiments were "fishing expeditions" across many variables at once.
- Intermediary Metabolism:
- Liver enzymes at 2.4 GHz; blood glucose rose in humans at 15 kV/m, 50 Hz.
- A 90-G field changed carbohydrate, protein and nucleic-acid metabolism. Muscle enzymes changed, and rabbits exposed at 30–40 kV/m became weaker.
- Re-analysis of the Mathewson study: its "controls" sat in stray 60-Hz fields of 0.18–9.15 V/m, and treating the lowest-dose group as the control revealed glucose rises.
- Mitochondrial energy production (10 GHz; the 2.4-GHz "household microwave oven" simulation).
- Kidney and salt metabolism differed by sex. Liver protein synthesis rose.
- Beischer's human study: blood fats (triglycerides) rose in 9 of 10 volunteers 1–2 days after 24 h at 1 G, 45 Hz.
- Cholesterol and plaque fell under magnetic fields. Vitamin B6 fell. Trace elements (copper, manganese, nickel and molybdenum at 2.4 GHz from 10 µW/cm²; copper, molybdenum and iron at 50 Hz from 1 kV/m).
- Reproduction, Growth and Healing:
- Sperm abnormalities and testicular mitochondria (5,000 V/m). Udintsev's testicular enzymes and testosterone. 7-kHz pulsed fields changed the testes at 30 G but not at 5 G. Oestrous and ovarian disturbance, with effects on offspring.
- Growth depression: 3 GHz at 153 µW/cm²; Noval at 0.5 V/m; chicks.
- Marino's multigeneration studies (10 and 15 kV/m, then 3.5 kV/m) and Grissett's primate work.
- Tumours: slower neuroblastoma growth at 12 G (Batkin & Tabrah); no effect on Ehrlich ascites tumour.
- Healing: Bassett's pulsed 65-Hz fields sped canine fracture repair. Marino's 5 kV/m fields slowed rat fracture healing (confirmed by Phillips). Microwaves (4,000 µW/cm²) sped guinea-pig skin-wound healing.
- Mutagenesis: rat chromosome aberrations at 50 and 500 µW/cm², 2.4 GHz. Mitotic disorders in lymphocytes. Ehrlich tumour cells under DC fields of 8–16 kV/m. Sperm chromosome translocations at 9.4 GHz. Cells in culture (rat kangaroo, Chinese hamster, monkey; 15,000-G static field). Mutations in fruit flies (20–30 MHz). Snapdragon plants.
- Uncontrolled Variables: McElhaney vs Martin & Gutman (bone tumours). Marino's glaucoma study. Battelle's opposite replicate results. Replication failures need analysis, not automatic dismissal.
- Summary: "no biological function which can be said to be impervious to nonthermal EMFs." Some reports will prove to be artifacts, but the core point stands. Mentions industry-side expert testimony (Schwan, Justesen, Michaelson, Carstensen, Miller) as the "stormy controversy." A mechanism need not be known before an effect is accepted.
- Introduction: Paul Weiss's whole-organism argument. The cybernetic "black box" approach versus the analytical, model-building approach.
- Cybernetic Approach: four empirical laws (all systems affected; effects largely independent of field type, with pulse modulation able to modify them; individual predisposition; adaptive or compensatory responses). A model: field detected, then CNS, then hormonal and electrical signals, then adaptation. Because electromagnetic stress is not consciously perceived, sub-cortical centres respond first. Within the organism's natural frequency range, fields can carry information; outside it, they provoke adaptation.
- Analytical Approach: five classes of physical process:
- Type 1, electronic excitation (rebutting the "0.02 eV thermal noise" argument).
- Type 2, polarization and dipole alignment.
- Type 3, field forces such as pearl-chaining of cells (10⁴–10⁶ V/m).
- Type 4, heat (any effect can always be asserted to be heat).
- Type 5, quantum and cooperative processes sensitive to 10⁻⁹ µW/cm²: Pilla's electrochemical information transfer (which modulated salamander regeneration), Zon's mitochondrial plasma resonance at gigahertz frequencies, Fröhlich's coherent excitation with sharp resonances in yeast growth and cell division, and Cope's Josephson junctions.
- Summary: the "Procrustean Bed" of heat and dipoles; how the "strong/weak/noise" categories and the "hot spot" theory arose; attacks on researchers. The authors' best guess is cooperative dipole interactions in nerve tissue, illustrated by Bowman's compass array. Szent-Györgyi: "There is more promiscuity among [molecules] than is generally believed."
- Introduction: from Maxwell and Hertz to Marconi's prediction of radar and Edison's electrification. By the second half of the 20th century, man-made EMFs dominated the Earth's electromagnetic environment. The best that can be said of US levels is that they do not cause shock or heating.
- Levels in the Environment:
- Broadcasting: AM, FM and TV population exposure (EPA's Tell & Mantiply). A 50-kW AM station stays above 1 µW/cm² out to about 3,280 ft. FM antennas; antennas on tall buildings; Mount Wilson's antenna farm; Sentinel Heights near Syracuse (about 1 µW/cm² over several square miles).
- Radar and relays: radar near airports and military bases; microwave-relay towers.
- Near the body: walkie-talkies and vehicle radios.
- Power frequencies: household appliances (Tables 10.4–10.5); about 500,000 miles of high-voltage lines (ground fields for 115–765 kV lines); security and anti-theft systems at 1–2 G; low-frequency magnetic fields across the whole San Francisco Bay Area produced by BART trains.
- Epidemiological Studies and Surveys:
- Environmental: suicide and power-line fields (Reichmanis, Perry, Marino & Becker). Wertheimer & Leeper vs Fulton. Children near high-frequency sources had faster pulse and breathing, higher blood pressure and slower recovery from a stress test. A French survey (Strumza) found no link between living near lines and doctor visits.
- Occupational, microwaves: cardiovascular and autonomic changes in 105 workers at 30 GHz. Sadchikova's large cohorts. Klimková-Deutschová's neurology. Sokolov's blood findings. Stress-hormone and endocrine changes. Gonadal effects. Radar and Down's syndrome (Cohen & Lilienfeld, not replicated). The three stages of "microwave disease."
- Occupational, the eyes: Zaret's 736 radar workers vs 559 controls, plus Majewska, Kheifets, Appleton, Odland, Aurell & Tengroth and Zydecki (1,000 vs 1,000). The capsular microwave cataract. Industry rebuttal (Michaelson & Osepchuk).
- Standards and power-frequency workers: Soviet 10 and 1 µW/cm² standards and power-frequency workplace rules (Table 10.7). Soviet, Spanish and American switchyard studies. Swedish (Knave) and Canadian (Hydro-Québec) reproductive findings.
- Analysis: the US heat-and-shock-only approach vs the Soviet approach ("the Soviet approach was the correct one"). Chronic, multi-frequency environmental exposure is largely unstudied, and its combined effects are unexplored. Under the stress model, epidemiology should show "a broad class of ills, rather than a specific disease." The West Virginia 765-kV decision as an example of the "dead-body theory," and the ethical argument against it. Risk evaluation as the alternative (BRH microwave ovens; California 1977; New York 1978), with criteria for weighing animal studies (species, strength, duration, body size).
- Summary: man-made fields are present at levels shown to affect biology. Uncontrolled exposure is a potential public-health risk. Regulators have been slow and have demanded the wrong kind of proof.
- Therapeutic Applications: electrical bone growth (Bassett, Pawluk & Becker, from the early 1960s). Current thresholds. Three clinical methods for nonunions (coils, steel pins, silver wire; Table 11.1). The mechanism is still unknown and is not piezoelectric.
- Acupuncture: ch'i, yin/yang and the 14 meridians. Whether points and meridians have a physical basis. The authors' pressure-free measurements: resistance minima at points such as LI-4 and P-7, lower AC impedance and higher capacitance, and lower resistance along meridians. Endorphin mediation (Sjölund & Eriksson; Pomeranz). Acupuncture fits the DC injury-signal theory.
- Impacts on Natural Ecological Systems: the Project Sanguine/Seafarer ELF antenna and pigeons (Graue), gull chicks (Southern) and migrating birds (Larkin & Sutherland; Williams). Flatworms grew two heads or two tails at 60 Hz (Marsh). Slime-mold cell division slowed (Goodman). Bees under high-voltage fields (Warnke; Wellenstein; Greenberg/EPRI). Eels and salmon perceive 0.007 V/m.
- Summary: restates the three-step argument and calls for "a new biology in which electromagnetic energy receives the critical consideration... it merits."
- The closing summary repeats the Chapter 11 summary. The intrinsic control role of electromagnetic energy is established by three lines of research: internal currents, sensing of natural fields, and responses to artificial fields. Weak fields within the physiological frequency range alter the EEG, the ECG, biological rhythms, calcium metabolism and behaviour. Fields outside it cause adaptive homeostatic responses, established "beyond good-faith dispute."
Practical Takeaways
What to actually do with this
See Also
Related books in the library