Overview
What this book is about
Martin Blank is a Columbia University membrane biophysicist. With his colleague Reba Goodman he spent about 25 years studying how weak electromagnetic fields act on living cells. In this book he argues that the long-standing assumption that non-ionizing radiation is harmless unless it heats tissue is wrong. That radiation includes power-line ELF (extremely low frequency, 50/60 Hz) and the radiofrequency/microwave (RF/MW) emissions of cell phones, cordless phones, WiFi, smart meters and towers. He calls all EMF "bioactive." His own lab and others found effects at exposures far below official limits: DNA strand breaks, activation of the cellular stress-protein response, leakage of the blood-brain barrier, lower melatonin and damaged sperm. Epidemiology links long-term exposure to brain and acoustic-nerve tumours, salivary-gland cancer, childhood leukaemia, Alzheimer's/ALS, depression and infertility. He frames the whole wireless era as "the largest biological experiment ever" (Leif Salford's phrase), run on billions of people without consent. (The title page of this edition carries a different subtitle: "What Science Tells Us about the Dangers of Cell Phones and Other WiFi-Age Devices.")
The book moves in three stages. Chapters 1–3 are a primer: Blank's own conversion from sceptic, the physics and units of EMF (gauss, µW/cm², SAR, frequency bands) and a tour of today's sources, from lightbulbs and the grid to cell towers and "dirty electricity." Chapters 4–7 present the evidence: DNA damage and stress proteins, cancer epidemiology, other health effects, and effects on birds, bees, trees and crops. Chapters 8–11 are an exposé of how the science became confused. They cover industry funding bias, the defunding and discrediting of researchers (Henry Lai, Jerry Phillips, George Carlo, Allan Frey, Milton Zaret), undisclosed conflicts of interest (Anders Ahlbom and others) and the tobacco-style strategy of "manufacturing doubt." Blank treats the WHO's Interphone study as a flawed case study, criticises the heat-only safety standards (ICNIRP, IEEE, FCC) and makes the case for the Precautionary Principle and the BioInitiative Report, which he helped create.
The last part is practical. Chapter 12 gives a detailed "prudent avoidance" playbook for home and work, covering meters, distance, phones, headsets, WiFi, appliances and bedrooms. Chapter 13 covers children, pregnancy, incubators, baby monitors, WiFi in schools and electrohypersensitivity (EHS). Chapter 14 describes therapeutic uses of EMF, which Blank offers as further proof that the body responds to very low doses. Chapter 15 is a call to act at personal, family and community level.
Blank writes as a scientist-turned-activist. He is openly on the precautionary side. He says he does not own a cell phone and refuses home WiFi. He also notes (in "About the Author") that he regularly serves as an expert witness in EMF cases. He does not ask readers to give up technology: his model is seat belts and airbags, or the aerosol industry reformulating after the CFC ban. The book was published in 2014, so it covers 2G/3G phones, WiFi, DECT cordless phones and smart meters, but not 5G or modern true-wireless earbuds.
Key Ideas
The core frameworks and findings
Contents
Chapter by chapter — click to expand
- Why people resist the message ("there's no way I am giving up my cell phone"); Blank insists no one needs to give up devices, using the aerosol/CFC reformulation as the model.
- Two goals: set criteria that make the technology safer, and create an informed citizenry.
- Leif Salford's "largest biological experiment ever": microwave transmitters held against the head daily; effects may take decades to appear.
- Headline claims previewed: DNA damage at typical phone-use levels; 240% same-side glioma after 10+ years; Israeli parotid-gland data; cancer 3× higher within 400 m of towers; Alzheimer's near power lines; 40% lower sperm counts; bees, birds and trees.
- Blank's background: lung surfactant in infant respiratory distress syndrome; a food-company job keeping air bubbles in ice cream stable; membrane electrochemistry.
- 1987: Reba Goodman's paper showing weak power-frequency fields change protein synthesis converts him; about 25 years of collaboration and 40+ joint papers.
- A hostile reception at a Department of Energy EMF review from two academics later found to be paid power-industry consultants; Henry Lai: many studies are "PR tools for the industry."
- EMF is unlike tobacco: it is the cornerstone of modern society, not an optional habit. Hence "prudent avoidance" for individuals and the Precautionary Principle for regulators, with car seat belts as the analogy.
- The 1998 Colorado lightning case: a golfer died of cardiac arrest without being struck directly (Lancet).
- Primer on electricity, magnetism, gauss and tesla (a fridge magnet is 50 G; the brain emits about 0.000001 G), power density (W/m², µW/cm²), SAR (W/kg) and frequency and wavelength.
- The EM spectrum: ELF (3–300 Hz, power lines), RF (3 kHz–300 GHz), microwave (300 MHz–300 GHz, phones and WiFi), infrared, visible light, UV, X-ray, gamma.
- Energy versus power; why "ionizing = dangerous, non-ionizing = safe" misleads. Blank says non-ionizing EMF can chemically change DNA: "All EMF is bioactive."
- Flight crews and cosmic radiation (breast cancer doubled after 5+ years); the history of non-thermal findings (d'Arsonval, Tesla, Danilewsky).
- Kurzweil's Law of Accelerating Returns means EMF sources will keep multiplying exponentially.
- Lightbulbs (fluorescent emits 20–40× more than incandescent; CFLs add higher frequencies and mercury), dimmers, the AC grid (60 Hz US / 50 Hz Europe), transmission (69–765 kV) versus distribution (15–30 kV) lines, and home wiring (running hot and neutral wires together cuts fields).
- EPA appliance table at 4 inches versus 3 feet: fields drop sharply with distance; hair dryers and razors are the hard cases.
- TV and radio, CRTs, microwave ovens (FDA allows 5 mW/cm² leakage when new, which grows as the oven ages, plus high ELF).
- Cordless phones: most now transmit at 2.4 or 5.8 GHz, and DECT base stations transmit continuously. Cell phones: growth figures from Martin Cooper (1973) to 5.9 billion subscriptions (2012).
- SAR critique: the FCC limit of 1.6 W/kg; industry does its own testing; a single worst-case point; the iPhone 4S rating assumes 5/8 inch from the head; phones transmit on standby; no cumulative standard.
- WiFi (2.4 GHz) and WiMAX, smart meters (a meter feeding several others), baby monitors, walkie-talkies and other wireless gadgets.
- Antennas: 480,058 US towers and 1.5M+ antennas (2012); hidden or camouflaged antennas; check AntennaSearch.com within 4 miles of home or school; broadcast antennas run at 50 kW.
- "Dirty electricity" (Sam Milham); high-exposure occupations; devices "on even when off."
- Cell theory; DNA as an electrical conductor (Barton) and a fractal antenna.
- Replication errors (about 120,000 per cell division), repair, apoptosis (programmed cell death), mutation and cancer.
- Lai & Singh strand-break studies (RF and ELF, at "safe" levels, with damage continuing after exposure); micronuclei; Rüdiger's 2009 review.
- Protein synthesis and the discovery of stress proteins (Ritossa's heat-shock response in fruit flies); hsp70.
- Blank and Goodman's stress-response findings (ELF within 5 minutes; also at cell-phone frequencies; reviews in 1998 and 2009).
- Electromagnetic tolerance: repeated or prolonged exposure blunts the response (Blank & Goodman 1996; DiCarlo/Litovitz chick embryos, −27% hsp70); a cumulative, ageing-like burden.
- John Snow and the 1854 cholera pump as the founding case for acting on epidemiology before a mechanism is proven.
- The 2009 Journal of Clinical Oncology review of 23 studies (with Joel Moskowitz): the 10 higher-quality studies showed harm, while the lower-quality ones were mostly industry-funded; studies of 10+ years of use showed significant risk.
- Glioma and acoustic neuroma figures (240% same-side glioma; 90%/390% acoustic neuroma); Hardell's young users; Sadetzki's parotid study and Israeli registry trends.
- Towers: the "Tower of Doom," the 400 m German study, Belo Horizonte; Neil Cherry's Sutro Tower study; Hallberg's FM/melanoma dose-response.
- Power lines (the cost of burying them: $800,000 per mile in Virginia), Milham's electrification and leukaemia-peak data, Wertheimer & Leeper; IARC 2002 (ELF) and 2011 (RF); the "thermal criterion" discredited.
- The Old Order Amish (no electricity): 40% lower cancer incidence in Ohio (Westman); lower heart disease, diabetes and suicide; no documented ADHD. Milham's "diseases of civilization."
- Alzheimer's, ALS and Parkinson's: Swiss power-line cohort, seamstresses, utility workers, Danish electricians, Swedish welders, Swiss train drivers, NIOSH death certificates (+87% for 60 Hz exposure), Garcia's 2007 meta-analysis.
- Male infertility: sperm counts halved over 50 years; Agarwal's usage groups and in-vitro exposure; the Australian SAR-vitality study.
- Blood-brain barrier: Frey 1975, Salford.
- Melatonin: Wang, Wilson (electric blankets), Burch (utility workers; >25 min/day of cell use), Davis (−8/−12/−15% melatonin at 2/3/4× ELF).
- Depression and suicide: Bridgend youth suicides and tower distance (Coghill); Finnish, Wolverhampton and US (Poole) power-line studies; Reichmanis; electrical workers.
- Cognitive effects by side of the head (Israeli Bioelectromagnetics papers).
- Eyes and ears: Zaret's microwave cataracts; Frey's microwave hearing (buzzing or clicking, headaches, dizziness; 200 MHz–3 GHz).
- EPA's Martin Halper: "I have never seen a set of epidemiological studies that remotely approached the weight of evidence that we're seeing with EMFs."
- Skrunda-1 (Latvia) Soviet radar, at up to 50× ICNIRP levels for 34 years: duckweed, pine trees, micronuclei in cows, fewer pied flycatchers.
- Magnetoreception (cryptochrome, magnetite; Heyers, Gegear, Kirschvink); Wiltschko's silvereyes; robins disoriented by fields 1/500 of Earth's.
- Tower collisions (Florida study: 42,384 dead birds; Kemper: 12,000 in one night; Manville: up to 50M/year); Balmori's disappearing sparrows (Valladolid), Everaert & Bauwens (Belgium); chicken embryos near phones died at 72.3% versus 11.9% (Youbicier-Simo); Fernie's kestrels.
- Colony Collapse Disorder figures; a cordless phone near hives (39.7% versus 7.3% of bees returning); total collapse (Pattazhy); 900 MHz phones by hives (queen laid half the eggs, 8× less honey stored, −70% population); Favre's 10-fold increase in "worker piping" swarm signals.
- Plants and trees: aspens in Faraday cages grew 74% more shoots and 60% more leaf area; mixed Michigan results; ash trees damaged by WiFi; PCBs doubled on pine needles under 400 kV lines; chlorophyll, tomato stress response, duckweed and tobacco oxidative stress; wheat yield 7% lower near lines; mung bean seedlings.
- Glaser's Navy bibliography; early military and industrial findings (Hughes Aircraft purpura, cataracts); Soviet low-level research and the microwave bombardment of the US Moscow embassy (Ambassador Stoessel's leukaemia).
- The 1990 EPA draft, its scrubbed carcinogen language, and a defunded, never-issued report.
- David Reynard on Larry King Live (1993); stock crashes; Tom Wheeler's (CTIA) unsupported "10,000 studies" claim, which in fact concerned microwave ovens; the $25M WTR programme and George Carlo's findings and ouster. (Blank says Wheeler was nominated in 2013 to head the "FDA"; it was actually the FCC.)
- The Lai "war-gaming" memo; Jerry Phillips and Motorola (spin requests, an edited paper, lost funding); Battelle's and Roti Roti's non-replications; the handling-stress mouse lymphoma example; the Danish cohort's design.
- Funding-bias statistics (tobacco, BPA, pharma, Lai's database, Huss, Moskowitz); the "scoreboard" tactic; the Swicord FDA–Motorola revolving door.
- Conflicts of interest: Ahlbom; Boice & McLaughlin.
- Fighting regulation: lobbying totals, TCA §704, California's smart-meter report omissions (Daniel Hirsch: smart meter exposure at 3 ft is about two orders of magnitude higher than a cell phone's, cumulative whole-body), San Francisco's SAR-label law and the CTIA boycott (Gavin Newsom's account).
- Military suppression: Frey told by the Office of Naval Research to stop publishing; Zaret's contracts cancelled.
- Thank You for Smoking; Maureen Dowd's "Are Cells the New Cigarettes?"; "Doubt is our product."
- The tobacco history: doctor-endorsed ads, Wynder & Graham (1950), the Tobacco Industry Research Committee's "Frank Statement," the Rylander/Philip Morris fraud ruling in Geneva, Wigand and Glantz, the 1997 settlement.
- Interphone: design, funding and firewall, results, and the flaws Blank lists (recall bias, selection bias, age exclusions, latency, weak exposure definitions, cordless users, four tumour types); delays; confusing media coverage; unreleased data; Jorn Olsen's point that it used up the available research funding.
- The Brown & Williamson objectives rewritten with "cell phone" in place of "cigarette"; the 1993 FDA memo; David Gee's table showing a 30–100 year lag between early warning and regulation.
- The CFC story (Lovelock, Rowland & Molina, DuPont's PR campaign, the 1978 US aerosol ban) as a model of acting before proof.
- Why setting a "dose" is hard; the limits of epidemiology (correlation, no true controls, long latency; the 30-year COSMOS cohort) and of laboratory work (mechanisms, not disease outcomes).
- ICNIRP and IEEE guidelines (short-term, established effects only); WHO endorsement; FCC SAR, antenna and smart-meter positions; FDA; NIOSH/OSHA; no US power-line limits.
- Blank's critique: heat-only, single-source, short-term; stress proteins appear across frequencies; "presumption of innocence does not work as a public health policy"; four revision criteria.
- Germany's Vorsorgeprinzip, the Rio Declaration, the Wingspread Statement; WHO's contrary evidence criteria.
- The 2006 Bioelectromagnetics Society (BEMS) mini-symposium (Blank chair, Michael Kundi, Cindy Sage) leading to the BioInitiative Report (edited by Sage and David Carpenter, 2007; updated 2012); its conclusions; the European Parliament's 522–16 vote; the 2009 Pathophysiology issue.
- Critics (IEEE COMAR, ACRBR, EPRI, the Mobile Manufacturers' Forum, the Health Council of the Netherlands, the French agency AFSSET) and Blank's rebuttals; the "so far, so good" falling-man joke.
- Policy steps from the European Environment Agency, plus Blank's additions (see Practical Takeaways).
- Blank's home survey (a surprise field from a second distribution line); an English leukaemia case where a crib stood against the wall behind the breaker panel; you cannot know without measuring.
- Why bother: unlike climate change, EMF exposure is within individual control.
- Measuring: the AM-radio static trick; gaussmeters for ELF (60/50 Hz, down to 0.1 mG; phone apps are unreliable); RF power-density meters (down to 0.01 µW/cm²); triple-axis meters; the TriField meter; retailer and advocacy sites; best practices (measure on your real schedule, many times, with devices on and off).
- Risk-benefit thinking (Kahneman, Slovic); dependence on devices ("nomophobia"; Sparrow's "Google effect"; Turkle); Blank's own trade-offs.
- The tactics list: concurrent exposures; power lines; transformers; antennas; electric blankets; cords; clocks; efficiency; lighting; dimmers; floor heating; microwaves; wall placement; airplane mode; pockets; SAR; cordless phones; headsets; laptops; razors and dryers; Ethernet; routers; power strips; smart meters; eyeglasses and mattresses; shielding; Stetzer filters; shielded cords; the workplace, with his Columbia lab survey (2008–09 readings).
- The origin of the issue in childhood leukaemia (Wertheimer & Leeper; Milham; IARC 2002/2011).
- Why children are at greater risk; the Helsinki 902 MHz EEG study; the UK Stewart Report (2000) discouraging non-essential use by children. Blank: "children should not use cell or cordless phones."
- Incubators (~12 mG versus the 3–4 mG leukaemia association; Bellieni's melatonin finding); baby monitors (DECT; Blank "strongly advises against" them near newborns).
- WiFi in schools (12,960 hours of exposure by graduation; WiFi school buses in Vail, Arizona); Blank's New York school meeting, after which the WiFi was quietly removed; tips for parents and advocacy groups.
- In the womb: De-Kun Li's miscarriage, asthma and obesity findings.
- EHS: WHO definition; Magda Havas's symptom list, including tinnitus; Powerwatch estimates (3–5% of Britons); Gro Harlem Brundtland; William Rea's 1991 provocation study (25 of 100 patients reacted consistently across three rounds and never to sham exposure); Olle Johansson's skin mast-cell findings; the Freiburger Appeal (3,000+ doctors; symptoms include tinnitus); Green Bank, West Virginia, and the National Radio Quiet Zone.
- The Russian SCENAR device's reported improvement rates; dose-response as a core biological principle.
- Wound healing and injury currents (Du Bois-Reymond; Penninger & Zhao); Robert Becker's regeneration work (Cross Currents); C.A.L. Bassett's non-contact pulsed-EMF bone healing at Columbia.
- Pain relief (TENS, arthritis, fibromyalgia, carpal tunnel, post-surgical pain, plantar fasciitis); cardiac bypass protection through EMF-induced hsp70 (built on Blank and Goodman's work); converting muscle fibre types by stimulation frequency; the idea of frequency-specific gene activation; Louis Slesin on frequencies that block cancer-cell growth.
- Devices (pacemakers, electroporation, microwave hyperthermia, TMS) and future uses (Parkinson's, schizophrenic auditory hallucinations, stroke rehab, tinnitus, ulcers, ADHD). The low doses involved reinforce Blank's case for stricter standards.
- "No conclusive proof" as the industry's central message; parallels with X-rays, tobacco, lead, asbestos, DDT, PCBs, CFCs and handwashing.
- The layering of sources: lightbulb, grid, radio, radar, TV, cordless phones, microwaves, cell phones, WiFi, Bluetooth devices, smart meters. The David Suzuki Foundation (1999): city exposures are "millions of times higher" than natural background.
- The two personal rules; a parent who, armed with information, got school WiFi routers removed.
Practical Takeaways
What to actually do with this
See Also
Related books in the library